Critics vs. Popular
Jan 29, 2006 ten to six pm
Saw these two stories next to each other on Google News and found it funny. Besides, posting a big picture like this gives you the illusion that something new and interesting appeared on Grumpy Gamer.
Hey! Pay attention! Except where otherwise noted, this site is
licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Other people's comments:
Posted by Altered Bonk on Jan 29, 2006 twenty to seven pm
Posted by PissedOffMonkeyIslandFan on Jan 30, 2006 ten to eight am
Posted by ScummFan on Jan 30, 2006 twenty five to nine am
Posted by eD on Jan 29, 2006 half past seven pm
touché!
Posted by David Thomsen on Jan 29, 2006 five past ten pm
Posted by jp-30 on Jan 30, 2006 ten past midnight
But the NZ Listener editorial this week helps put it all into perspective. :P
Posted by spaceship789 on Jan 30, 2006 ten past one am
Well, it looks like I am the third New Zealand poster in a row. I am not surprised. Last week I saw a guy walking around Auckland with a Monkey Island Tshirt. (fan made?)
Posted by Tramb on Jan 30, 2006 quarter past six am
(I won't reveal my nationality to avoid (justified) teasing ;)
Posted by JP on Jan 31, 2006 twenty to one am
And I don't think that editorial is "Tall Poppy Syndrome", Welch is very supportive of the movie, just ranting at the amount of meaningless awards dished out for art. You could probably draw parallels to the gaming industry. Every game box has some sort of award or GOTY sticker from some website or magazine or other that I've never heard of.
Posted by David Thomsen on Jan 30, 2006 twenty five to eight am
I kind of agree with the editorial, though. It irritates me that every second book in the store claims to be 'the international number one bestseller', and has a shining commendation from Time magazine. It's a bit unfair to say that every film that isn't a turkey wins an award, though. And I'm quite sure Toa Fraser doesn't have the budget to win an award on advertising alone. Denis has used the usual journalistic tactic of juxtaposing some ideas and leaving it to the reader to conclude that point B does not necessarily relate to point A.
Posted by Ninomojo on Jan 30, 2006 quarter past three am
Games need more good writers like you.
Posted by gnome on Jan 30, 2006 quarter to six am
Posted by Haggis on Jan 30, 2006 twenty past seven am
Posted by David Thomsen on Jan 30, 2006 quarter to eight am
Posted by Joshi on Jan 30, 2006 quarter past two pm
Posted by Ron Gilbert on Jan 30, 2006 quarter past two pm
Posted by Agustí on Jan 31, 2006 twenty to six am
The implications of such a fact are frightening...
Posted by Elaine Marley on Jan 31, 2006 eight am
Posted by Joshi on Feb 2, 2006 half past noon
Posted by Jeff on Jan 30, 2006 twenty five to four pm
Man in dress = BIG LAFFS!
Posted by Kubat on Jan 30, 2006 ten to five pm
Posted by Jat316sob on Jan 30, 2006 quarter past six pm
Posted by spaceship789 on Jan 30, 2006 twenty five to eleven pm
But the great thing about popular culture is that it provides the back drop to most peoples lives. Search within the backdrop of trashy popular culture and there is still a unique good feeling worthy of nostagia.
Pop trash can be quite inspiring.
Take maniac mansion for instance. Arguably the films that it was parodying were crap. Horror movies and those eighties kids movies involving a bunch of kids sneaking away on an adventure. Looking back on most of them, they were pretty poor. Yet maniac mansion managed to capture the zeitgeist of that period, just with a massive moon in the sky, the sound of chirping crickets and three kids outside an old house. It captured their dreams and their motivations, no matter how silly - ie become a rock star, a writer etc etc.
Theres no reason why someone couldn't make an adventure game involving all the stupid pop trash of a particular moment in time, and mail it round. People would be able to connect to it, just because the things that it is subtley paradoying are relevant to them. Society always have pop trash, but the closer you are to the pop trash the closer you are to influencing the minds of the masses.
Posted by haysoos on Jan 31, 2006 ten past nine pm
I dunno really, but I'd hazard a guess that most of the people who came out of "Big Momma's House 2" said "awww, that was shit." So maybe it wouldn't be actually popular.
Posted by ZIPBAPBADA on Feb 7, 2006 five past four am
Posted by El Milanes on Feb 15, 2006 twenty five past ten pm